Making homemade chocolate ice cream is really simple to do but for the best ever recipe some practice in patience must be exercised. The Best Milk Chocolate Ice Cream: Graeter's. Kemps Old Fashione… In this tiny test group, some judges didn’t care for caramel, while others adored it. Each taste tester gave each scoop a rough score out of 10 (The higher the score, the better the scoop.). Here’s our lineup: 1. The only way to know your favorite is to try it yourself. For over a month, our freezer at SEHQ was filled with only one thing: chocolate ice cream. We decided that the best way to compare brands would be to test them by the quality of the most classic ice cream flavor: chocolate. With this criterion in mind, we started tasting, one by one. Ad Choices, The Best Chocolate Ice Cream You Can Buy at the Store. A bite of Breyers chocolate ice cream transported several tasters back to their childhoods. We considered two major characteristics: flavor and texture. And they’re just begging to be paired with these indulgent desserts! But we didn't rule out stabilizers completely, because they contribute to superior scoopability and longevity. My colleagues insist that the very best brand of chocolate ice cream comes from Friendly's all-natural line. Stir in the chocolate and vanilla … Just pure cocoa flavor. These people think about food all day long (they create our magazines and books), so they have some qualified palates. That means there were no swirls, cookie chunks, fluffy mallows or extra mix-ins. Rhoda also loved its "clean and classic dark chocolate flavor," which has fruity/berry notes that round things out. To find the best of the best, we went to our local grocer and scooped up 10 of the most popular ice cream brands. That means there were no swirls, cookie chunks, fluffy mallows or extra mix-ins. Just pure cocoa flavor. Additionally, of every single carton, it was Breyers that was emptiest at the end of the tasting. Like most ice creams, it's best if you let it sit on the counter for a bit before digging in—straight out of the freezer it's slightly cocoa-powdery on the tongue, but once it starts melting around the edges, it can't be beat. This scoop definitely packed that creamy flavor, leaping bounds above the rest of the pack. It has both rich, nuanced chocolate flavor and an airy lightness that make it refreshing. Learn how to make ice cream without a machine. Without question, it was my personal favorite from this round of tastings. I’ll definitely think twice before spending big bucks on a name brand again. BUY IT: Graeter's Dutch Milk Chocolate Ice Cream, $80 for a six-pint sampler pack at Williams Sonoma. ", BUY IT: Naturally Friendly's Premium Chocolate Ice Cream, $5 for 1 1/2 quarts on Instacart. We also tasted Blue Bunny, primarily because their more natural vanilla bean flavor won our vanilla ice cream taste test. Unbeknownst to the testers, this ice cream was from a Wisconsin company. Did your favorite scoop the competition? For those people, Graeter's is coming to a store near you. We tasted 15 brands of chocolate ice cream (from dark to milk and Belgian to Dutch) to determine the very best one. Eh, good luck finding space. (Upscale brands or cool packaging can unfairly sway people’s opinion, even though it doesn’t have a thing to do with flavor.) Of the milk chocolate varieties we tried, Graeter's had the most complex chocolate flavor, but that didn't take away from its supreme milky, creaminess. (And they’re just begging to be paired with these indulgent desserts!) To gather a non-biased opinion, we decided to conduct a blind taste test. Taste of Home wanted to help. Combine sugar, milk, salt, and cocoa powder in a saucepan over medium heat, stirring constantly. They were sampled blind by a panel of Epicurious editors and staff in order from lightest to darkest, since chocolate experts generally recommend tasting in a similar order when sampling bars. Best on a Stick. Unfortunately, they don't offer a less-stablizer-packed chocolate option and I personally found that it had a gummy texture and oily finish. Taste of Home is America's #1 cooking magazine. And while it'll definitely give you those familiar childhood vibes, we'd wager it tastes better than that frosty ever did. (Selfless, we know.). Some preferred a soft scoop, while others liked their ice cream firm and frozen. Photo by Chelsea Kyle, Food Styling by Joe Sevier, The Best Chocolate Gifts for Any Occasion, Naturally Friendly's Premium Chocolate Ice Cream, $5 for 1 1/2 quarts on Instacart, Graeter's Dutch Milk Chocolate Ice Cream, $80 for a six-pint sampler pack at Williams Sonoma, Van Leeuwen Chocolate Ice Cream, $89 for a six-pint sampler pack at Goldbelly, Three Twins Bittersweet Chocolate Ice Cream, Turkey Hill All-Natural Belgian-Style Ice Cream. To revisit this article, select My Account, then View saved stories. To revisit this article, visit My Profile, then View saved stories. Our methodology and the full list of ice creams tasted is at the bottom of the page; first, the rankings: While you could consider Friendly's natural chocolate ice cream offering a darker option, it's nowhere near as rich as those labelled "dark chocolate." We decided that the best way to compare brands would be to test them by the quality of the most classic ice cream flavor: chocolate. As we gathered around the table, the smiles grew with each spoonful. To find the best chocolate ice cream, we gathered seven nationally available products and asked 21 tasters to sample them plain and in mini ice cream cones. This dark horse captivated the testers with its creamy texture and balanced chocolate flavor, and its larger size makes it a great party staple. Add the remaining half-and-half and the heavy cream. Learn how to make ice cream without a machine.